Gemba a weblog about better ways to makes things better

Want to Learn Kaizen? Forget About It

Kaizen starts in the brain, so understanding the working of the brain is essential to doing kaizen better. A June 4, 2007 New Scientist article titled Forgetfulness is a tool of the brain suggests that if we want to learn kaizen, we also have to forget.

According to a new study, the brain only chooses to remember memories it thinks are most relevant, and actively suppresses those that are similar but less used, helping to lessen the cognitive load and prevent confusion.

Stanford University researchers Brice Kuhl and colleagues used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to measure the brain activity of a group of healthy adults while they performed a simple memory test. The experimenters found:

"Whenever you’re engaging in remembering, the brain adapts. It’s constantly re-weighting memories," says Kuhl. "In this simple test, we see it reverse memory to weaken competing memories. This is something that probably happens a lot in the real world."

This is like a 5S of the mind. Sort and straighten. What new memories do I keep, and what do I throw out? The brain is constantly prioritizing and making room for new things. Our brain is a pretty fantastic instrument. The fact that our brains are constantly doing 5S is a good argument for us to do the same in our physical space.

The overall idea of forgetting something to learning something new is very much in the spirit of kaizen. To improve, we need to let go of old ways so that we can change them and make better ways.

On a related note, on June 4, 2007 the MIT News published an articled titled Brain uses both neural 'teacher' and 'tinkerer' in learning which has interesting parallels to standard work, variation, kaizen and learning through experimentation.

The investigative team of Emilio Bizzi, Uri Rokni, and Sebastian Seung at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute investigator found:

While most people need peace and quiet to cram for a test, the brain itself may need noise to learn, a recent MIT study suggests. In experiments with monkeys, the researchers found that neural activities in the brain gradually change, even when nothing new is being learned. Challenging the monkeys to adjust their task triggered systematic changes in their neural activities on top of this background "noise."

The brain needs "noise" to learn. Variation and error correction is an essential part of the neourscience of learning, in this new theory

"What surprised us most was that the neural representation of movement seems to change even when behavior doesn't seem to change at all," said Sebastian Seung, professor of physics and computational neuroscience and a Howard Hughes Medical Institute investigator. "This was a surprising degree of instability in the brain's representation of the world."

Uri Rokni explained:

"Our theory holds that the learning brain has the equivalent of a 'teacher' and a 'tinkerer'--a learning signal and noise in the learning process, respectively.

There is a sensei (teacher) in your brain, guiding your experiments (tinkerer).

"In producing a specific piece of text, the tinkerer just randomly changes the words, while the teacher continually corrects the text to make it have the right meaning. The teacher only cares about the meaning and not the precise wording. When the teacher and tinkerer work together, the text keeps changing but the meaning remains the same. For example, the tinkerer may change the sentence 'John is married' to 'John is single,' and the teacher may correct it to 'John is not single.'

The tinkerer in the brain tries new things, while the sensei in the brain guides the experiment according to certain rules and principles, in the example above so that the novel sentence retains the same meaning or value.

"In the same way, learning in the brain has two components--error-correction and noise--so that even though the neural representation keeps changing, the behavior remains fixed. We think the tinkerer, that is the noise, is not merely a nuisance to the teacher but is actually helping the teacher explore new possibilities it wouldn't have considered otherwise."

The parallel in the Lean world may be that the set behavior is Standard Work, the noise is the naturally occurring variation in any system, and the actions to explore these new options is kaizen.

According to Rokni, the concepts of redundant networks and "noisy learning" have important implications for neurobiology. "I don't think this concept of redundancy--that the brain can say the same thing in different ways--has really been fully appreciated until now," he said.

This may also have parallels to this redundancy in Toyota's design approach. The so-called set-based concurrent engineering where multiple design options are explored until the very end, increasing the "noise" in the overall design work flow, but ending up with a better overall result and more learning. This is in contrast to narrowing down the design options early and struggling to make it work.

If this this new model of learning and the brain is right, it confirms Toyota's claim that their management system is powered by their greatest asset: people and their brains.

By Jon Miller - June 13, 2007 7:39 PM

Comments

What a great post! It kind of reminds me of inattentional blindness.

In one experiment subjects watched a video in which two groups of people (wearing black and white t-shirts) pass a basketball back among themselves. In one version a woman in a gorilla suit stops in the middle, faces the camera, and pounds her chest before walking out of the scene. After watching the video 50% of the subjects did not report seeing the gorilla.

I see similar examples of inattentional blindness every day in the plant!

Rob

PS: Can you change your link for 63buckets, to learnsigma.com please? Note its learn not lean, thanks!

Posted by: Rob - June 14, 2007 3:09 PM

Change made to the link. Very nice new website by the way Rob. I'll look through in more detail later.

By the way, do you know where to get a copy of that video with the gorilla in it?

Posted by: Jon - June 14, 2007 4:18 PM

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated to filter spam and inappropriate content. There may be a delay before your comment is published.




Recent Artices
Hospital Improves Patient Flow: 90% Seen in Under 60 Minutes

There is a small hospital in Hiroshima, Japan which has been practicing the Toyota more>>

By Jon Miller - January 6, 2009 9:52 AM0 comments>>
Planning for One Piece Flow Cells

Bas Timmermans from the Netherlands asked a question about OEE and one piece flow cells: more>>

By Jon Miller - January 5, 2009 12:29 PM0 comments>>
Virtual Factory Tours on YouTube

Keep your chin up, global manufacturing! Even though new factory orders dipped recently to record more>>

By Jon Miller - January 4, 2009 4:53 PM5 comments>>
Ask Gemba

We want to make it easier to start conversations and find answers here at more>>

By Jon Miller - January 3, 2009 1:57 PM2 comments>>
5 Ways to Boost Kaizen Consciousness in 2009

Improved quality, reduced cost, better teamwork, faster response to customer needs - there are as more>>

By Jon Miller - January 1, 2009 11:19 PM1 comments>>
HP Printer Pokayoke Example

This is a new HP C7250 printer we purchased a few weeks ago. It's quite more>>

By Jon Miller - December 30, 2008 12:53 AM0 comments>>
Yaruki: The Will to Win Even in Tough Times

RC Bhargava, the Chairman, Maruti Suzuki India recounts the story of Maruti Suzuki and how more>>

By Jon Miller - December 28, 2008 7:53 PM3 comments>>
9 Surprises for U.S. Manufacturing in 2009

1. Will you shut up about kaizen, Tom? Newly appointed U.S. Secretary of Agriculture more>>

By Jon Miller - December 24, 2008 4:05 PM4 comments>>
Let's Do Kaizen, Not Kaizan

It doesn't really matter how you pronounce the Japanese word for continuous improvement through more>>

By Jon Miller - December 23, 2008 12:20 PM0 comments>>
Answers to Lean Thinking Crossword Puzzle #1

Spoiler alert! The answers to Lean Thinking Crossword Puzzle #1 are below. Here are the more>>

By Jon Miller - December 20, 2008 2:20 AM0 comments>>
Lean Thinking Crossword Puzzle #1

Here is a quiz we used as a review of lean knowledge for the team more>>

By Jon Miller - December 19, 2008 3:24 AM0 comments>>
Field Report from Gemba Tour #62, Part 4

Today was day-long visit to a company who is 13 years on their lean more>>

By Jon Miller - December 18, 2008 8:16 AM1 comments>>
Field Report from Gemba Tour #62, Part 3

Today wast the Toyota plant tour day of our Japan Kaikaku Experience #62. I noticed more>>

By Jon Miller - December 17, 2008 5:21 AM0 comments>>
Field Report from Gemba Tour #62, Part 2

I have seen the future of logistics, and it is green. Today we visited more>>

By Jon Miller - December 16, 2008 7:08 AM3 comments>>
Field Report from Gemba Tour #62, Part 1

The last few weeks haven't been very productive ones for writing blog articles due more>>

By Jon Miller - December 15, 2008 5:34 AM2 comments>>
If Blame Helped Solve Problems...

...the interview with Newt Gingrich on Fox News would be a brilliant way to get more>>

By Jon Miller - December 5, 2008 11:07 PM8 comments>>
$34,000,000,000

Sigh. Chrysler wants $7 billion. They asked Congress for this taxpayer money in a 14-page more>>

By Jon Miller - December 2, 2008 8:11 PM5 comments>>
PDCA is About Not Telling Lies

This circle doesn't lie. In fact one could say that used properly, it is more>>

By Jon Miller - December 1, 2008 5:39 AM6 comments>>
With Competitors Like These, Who Needs a Winning Business Strategy?

Larry, Curly and Moe go to Washington image credit: Wall Street Journal As we more>>

By Jon Miller - November 27, 2008 10:00 PM4 comments>>
It's a Lousy Time to Implement Lean

Author, teacher and our friend Bob Emiliani from the Center for Lean Business Management pointed more>>

By Jon Miller - November 25, 2008 8:08 PM4 comments>>
Blogroll
Improve With me
Lean Companies
Agile Management Blog
Curious Cat
DailyKaizen
Evolving Excellence
Fashion-Incubator
Got Boondoggle?
Lean Blog
Lean Insider
Lean Builder
Lean Reflections
Lean Six Sigma Academy
Learn Sigma
Productivity Cafe
Reforming Project Management
Shmula
The Lean Thinker
Thinking for a Change
TPM Log